I Will Do My Worst #7

I Will Do My Worst #7

In my first installment of this column (Issue 8, one year ago), I tried to take in the landscape of current Bandcamp alternatives like Subvert, Ampwall, Faircamp and Mirlo. In this column I will revisit things (and explain a new Counterforce project).

State of Subvert

One year later and Subvert is an actual live website touting almost 40,000 "members" (by comparison, Bandcamp currently has around 430,000 artists based on my count). It looks nice – like, it is certainly well designed and has plenty of funding. I have yet to organically come across a band sharing their music on Subvert, but that might just be the bubble I'm in. I just dug around the site for the first time, and most of the bands I found tagged with "hardcore punk" looked like bands with managers. Promo pics and bios written in the 3rd person. Numerous hashtags to cover a broad range of hip subgenres.

And maybe it's the Subvert presentation, but it feels quite commercial, like truly shopping for digital music. Every item has a big clear "Add to cart" button and two different prices (the non-member and member price). There's a lot of dollar signs and there are no scrollbars. A lot of Linktrees. I feel like I'm in a digital mall. Or a really cool record store with white walls, and a lot of people here are trying to get rich, famous, or both.

But that's just vibes and I admit I'm being a hater. My original main critique of Subvert (besides the vibes) is that it intends to be yet another huge, centralized platform. Subvert is not a tool that empowers you to put your own music online. It is just another Bandcamp with a nicer business model. For me, that means it carries all the same issues as Bandcamp.

Bandcamp is a centralized service. A huge part of our culture relies on it, and it can change the rules, decide to sell out, slowly enshittify, and might just go offline one day. Subvert is no different, it's just at an earlier stage of this progression. The "cooperative" aspect is admirable, but a huge, global coop of 40,000+ members does not seem sustainable and functional to me. Even from my quick tour of the site, I can tell a lot of the members have different interests, ideals, and values. Likely some of their members have opinions I despise (but sell a lot of records). The power of a cooperative is that you can work with a small group of people with whom who share affinity. Large cooperatives are best when they are cooperatives made up of smaller cooperatives! Subvert is a single platform and doesn't offer any of that potential. They have built their nice minimalist record store but that doesn't help me if I don't want to be on the shelf next to some of their other members, or don't agree with where the profits go, or don't trust them to keep my stuff online.

HEAR NOTHING .net

A year ago, I expressed high hopes for Mirlo, an open-source project developing the software to host a site like Bandcamp (or Subvert) with the expected features: bands can create their profile, put up their music for streaming, sell downloads if they like, sell physical merch, etc.

"Open-source" means that the software is free and anyone can copy or contribute to the code. At the time, Mirlo was just a single instance at http://mirlo.space but they were beginning to work towards making the software something that anyone can use to create their own Mirlo. I've been helping them in this, by being one of the people encouraging them and offering to try to host my own Mirlo as soon as it become possible (and hopefully offer useful feedback in the process).

All that has now culminated in HEAR NOTHING. HEAR NOTHING is a Mirlo instance, slightly adjusted for punks (the background is black, duh), and hosted on the same server that hosts all of The Counterforce's online projects. HEAR NOTHING is not open to anyone, we'll never have 40,000 artists (I doubt there will ever be more than 100 because hard drives are expensive).

HEAR NOTHING will be a place for small labels and bands I care about, projects of people who contribute to The Counterforce, or anyone who shares our vision of trying to push hardcore punk off of platforms like Spotify, Instagram, and Bandcamp. Instead of joining one big alt-cooperative-Subvert-Bancamp, we can make our own. Mirlo is the perfect tool to allow, small collectives, cooperatives, labels, distros, and crews of friends to put their own music online autonomously with their own goals and parameters, rather than having to agree with 40,000+ members.

Mirlo also has a lot of open and radical ways to follow bands and labels that let people keep up with projects they care about, but without replicating the siloed, algorithm-driven hype machine of corporate social media. If a band or label has a profile on any Mirlo site, you can follow them from the Fediverse, subscribe to email updates or follow via RSS. There are projects like Fairplayer which will soon allow you to search and browse releases from multiple Mirlo instances (and elsewhere) in one place.

HEAR NOTHING is, as far as I know, the first Mirlo site outside of https://mirlo.space (the "main" Mirlo site). Right now it's not that easy to make your own Mirlo. The Mirlo developers seem like great people, and they are working hard on making the process of self-hosting Mirlo easier. If you think this is really exciting and want to participate, but have no technical skill, get in touch if you want to put your music on HEAR NOTHING. If you do have technical skill, and want to try hosting your own Mirlo, check out their documentation (although it's still a bit crunchy).

Faircamp

The nice thing about Mirlo is that someone like me can set up HEAR NOTHING and provide a music site for a lot of my friends, and they don't have to do anything more complicated than just uploading their songs and artwork.

But Faircamp is still the true DIY solution, and I still love Faircamp! We published a really nice how-to for making your own band website with Faircamp, but to recap Faircamp is great if you just want to take a record or catalog, turn it into a nice website, and throw it online. No merch store, no paid downloads, just your music on a website. Besides the "putting a website online" part, the toughest aspect of Faircamp was you had to fiddle with metadata text files and a command line utility. So it great news for aspiring digital DIY punks everywhere that Faircamp 2.0.0 was recently released and brings a GUI interface – that means you can run it in a window like a normal computer program and click and drag stuff around to build your site.


I'm pretty excited about where things have been going with the projects I've found have the most potential, Mirlo and Faircamp. Both are steadily progressing into real alternatives that can be explored by anyone who wants a truly DIY alternative to the corporate platforms that dominate how we share music online. It's easier and easier to try alternatives. If you do build something for your band or label with Mirlo or Faircamp, or if you know of other projects please get in touch and tell me about it!